Article Critical Analysis Employee Retention Essay

The focal point of this survey is to critical analysis of the article Targeted Employee Retention: Performance based and Job-Related Differences in Reported Reasons for Staying written by John P. Hausknecht, Julianne Rodda, and Michael J. Howard. In this article authors explains that employees are going more and more competitory within the planetary sphere. They stress the fact that enrolling people to run into the administration ‘s human resource demands is merely half the conflict in the war for endowment. The other half is maintaining people. In the undermentioned paper we will critically explicate writer ‘s position of employee keeping, the strengths and failings of the article and methods of maintaining the employee in private sectors they used.

Article Critical Analysis: Employee Retention

The writers of the article stated that for one person, calling is by and large of import to a individual who has merely been employed. This single might give all his energies developing his calling by farther surveies and deriving more experience relating to his calling and leting himself to be mentored by his senior employees. In contrary, a individual who has seen it all might be interested in accomplishing more out of his calling ; this might include come oning within the ranks of the administration, as the present occupation does non excite or dispute him any longer.

Harmonizing to the Burt, ( 2007 ) , companies raise wages for whole classs of people without sing how many persons stay largely for the money. They announce dearly-won fringe benefits such as tuition reimbursement without cognizing whether employees might prefer something else. They use the same keeping techniques for sales representative, say, as computing machine coders -even though the two groups are likely to hold different involvements.

The writers of the article examine that keeping ever begins with enlisting, and one key is to avoid conveying in employees who are guaranteed to be unhappy. Another key to engaging for keeping is by giving people a thorough and accurate description wart-and-all-of the company and the occupation they are using for.

To discourse about the methods of keeping they genuinely stressed the word ‘incentive ‘ as a ‘motive or incitation to action ‘ ( as besides define in oxford lexicon ) . Hom, Roberson & A ; Ellis, ( 2008 ) besides stated that virtually all theories of motive accept that money influences employees ‘ public presentation to a certain extent ( ref ) . At the same scenario the Harvard Business School Press ( 2005: 173 ) stresses the fact that no-one can honestly state that fiscal inducements do n’t count in their professional lives ( cited in Hom, Roberson & A ; Ellis, 2008, p. 78 ).

The writers of the article expressed that after all, people have mortgages, college tuition, and other disbursals to pull off. But money entirely is n’t plenty to actuate people to stand out on the occupation. In fact, the most effectual inducement system blends pecuniary with nonmonetary signifiers of wages -and frequently it ‘s the nonmonetary types that prove the most motivative. The writers said that it must understand what employees most value: congratulations, the authorization to make their work and do determinations, and support from their directors when they have made a error.

Fiscal options ( employee portion strategies )

Fiscal options are really focusing methods of the employee keeping.According to Vidal, Valle, & A ; Aragon, ( 2007 ) , in the long term, fiscal options might non be a good option. What will go on to employees ‘ motive during the market downturns? If an person is dissatisfied with the payment or dividends received, the consequence may be poorer public presentation. The dissatisfaction and demand for higher returns might actuate him to put his vested options elsewhere, giving him room besides to look for another occupation with higher wage.

Higher wage scheme

Morrell, Loan-Clarke, Arnold & A ; Wilkinson, ( 2008 ) say that in an economic system of chronic labor deficits, administrations compete for limited human resources. To outbid rivals, administrations frequently entice workers to go forth their present occupations with better wage bundles, doing rewards to coiling upwards.

Pay-for-performance strategies

Hom, Roberson & A ; Ellis, ( 2008 ) stated that a alteration in conditions from the footing of employee rating and wages makings and accomplishments development has led to greater accent on employee parts, through this pattern, public presentation assessment and direction by aims organisation. The alteration is most obvious in the compensation agreements for senior direction, although a series of non-management workers, many companies have introduced similar steps.

To discoursing the grounds for maintaining occupation public presentation writers found that superior and top direction are predictive of employee motive. Blau, ( 2007 ) contended that perceptual experiences of direction support could increase satisfaction and motive, cut down emphasis, and better occupation public presentation.

Percepts of employees about legion facets of their work environment explained occupation satisfaction. Mache, ( 2007 ) defines equity as a perceptual experience based on “ the procedures through which determinations are made. ” For Hom, Roberson & A ; Ellis, ( 2008 ), equity is the relationship between occupation public presentation and subsequent wagess and penalty. As a manner to better accomplishments degrees, better public presentation and enhance feelings of self-pride, and that the employees involved in preparation activities ( Morrell, Loan-Clarke, Arnold & A ; Wilkinson, 2008 ).

Harmonizing to the writers income is a criterion by which a worker can measure comparative additions from the investings of clip, work, and accomplishments in a occupation. Wagess can be intrinsic and extrinsic in nature. Intrinsic wagess, harmonizing to Vidal, Valle, & A ; Aragon, ( 2007 ) , are derived undertaking or work it interesting and ambitious work, the effectivity of autonomous and duties, assortment, creativeness, the chance to utilize their accomplishments and abilities, and of sufficient feedback on a individual ‘s effortsand other factors. Although external wagess, is the interaction with others in the work from the wages. They are based on factors such as the quality of human relationships, the aid and support of co-workers and supervisors ( Mache, 2007 )

Strengths and Weakness of the Article

The strength of the article is the calling individuality reflects the way of calling motive, calling penetration and adaptability, reflects the waking up, strength and permanent power.. They besides point out that some of the dimensions, like need promotion and committedness to managerial work are most applicable to directors in hierarchal administrations. Before continuing with calling occupation rating in an administration it is better to explicate the three dimensions of calling motive i.e. , calling individuality, calling penetration and calling resiliency.

Typically, calling information, and the strengths and failings through self-exploration and environmental values, involvements and accomplishments, to research, for illustration, to discourse calling involvements with equals or household members. Vidal, vale, Aragon ( 2007 ) pointed out, the staff know their strengths and failings are more likely to turn out the behaviour aimed at bettering the accomplishments failings.


Harmonizing to the article it is conceived that the embedding of the work is an of import intermediary construction between work and on-the-job factors and employee keeping. It represents the position of a focal point on the accretion of by and large non-emotional grounds, employees will non go forth work, including one stuckness, inactiveness, or prejudice is a key-mediating concept between specific on-the-job and off-the-job factors and employee keeping. It represents a focal point on the accumulated, by and large non-affective, grounds why employees would non go forth a occupation, which comprise a kind of stuckness, inactiveness, or bias toward the position quo. Career direction plans may or may non bring forth positive results for administrations and their employees.

If plans raise aspirations to unrealistic degrees or do employees certain that their personal calling program do non fit those of their administration, cognition of organizational calling chances may coerce them away from an administration instead than adhering them to it ( Morrell, Loan-Clarke, Arnold & A ; Wilkinson, 2008 ). Directors need to understand how single planning, organizational calling information, and perceived lucifers between persons and organizational calling programs combine to determine and stimulate employees ‘ calling attitudes and behaviors.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *